Overexposed

Mary Katherine Duhon

Erin Prescott

Marguerite Moreau

Sheila Prescott

David Maldonado

Stuart Shelby

Jake Allyn

Jimmy Cowls

Ashley Wood

Brian Prescott

Sam Chance

Taylor Cowls

William Tate

Aiden

Taylor Ashley Murphy

Joanna Schwartz

Suzy Weller

Rachel

Damon Carney

Pete Cowls

Brooks Ryan

Deputy Tim

Lacey Lett

Herself

Tiffany Feese

Vanessa Rodgers

Katie Hooley

Cheerleader

Collin Place

Teen Boy

Josiah Overstreet

Neighbor

Ginger Gilmartin

Woman from Town

Glenda Radigonda

Principal

Conor Allyn

State Trooper

Becky Bartlett

Towns Person

Gina D. Brewer

Townsperson

Joy Brewer

Townsperson

Stacy Casaluci

Volunteer

Geren Davis

Townsperson

JR Hatchett

Volunteers / Missing person

Desiree' Jones

Townsperson

Jessica Knobbe

Townsperson

Paige Kriet

Townsperson

Jessi Kyle

Townsperson

Nick Marchetti

Busboy

Justin Marre

Extra

Paige McGarvin

Martha

Kristen Melling

Mom

Dale Niehaus

Townsfolk

Jonnie Parnell

Townfolk

Ginifer Ree

Townsperson

Rita Scranton

Volunteer

Tryston Skye

Towns Person / Student

Shannon Moree Smith

Mrs. Rodgers, Vanessa's Mom

Ryan Cole Stratton

Townsperson

Nick Swezey

Townsperson

Marshall Virden

Towns person

Charles Walker

Town hall Member

Delores Wheeler

City Council Member, Joanna's Mom

Morgan Lynn Krueger

High School Student (uncredited)

Alyssa Laronde

Student

Charles Lipps

Teacher (uncredited)

Hasan Shah

Student (uncredited)

Amelia White

Townsperson (uncredited)