Real

Danelle Simpson

Caitlyn

Marty Lathrop

Sam Reed

John Horstmann

Cole Donnel

David Krist

Chance

Stephen Krist

Jesus

Clay Williams

Satan

Nick Osborne

Connor

Tyler Kreiner

Adam

Denise Wampler

Caitlyn's Mother

Kevin Piotrowski

Caitlyn's Father

Reagan Wilkinson

Aaron

Ken Morris

Doctor

Lou Kreiner

Jason

Jeff Krist

Gambler